My glycol concentration dropped — am I at risk of freezing or bursting?

The call that follows a cold weekend

Every winter, a facilities manager somewhere walks into a plant on a Monday morning and finds that a chilled-water loop has been sitting idle through a freeze and something has gone wrong. The glycol concentration was checked at commissioning and never looked at again. The loop was topped up with plain water to make up a small leak. And nobody asked whether the system was designed for freeze protection, or only for burst protection.

Those two words are used interchangeably in purchase specifications, and they describe different things. The difference is the reason a concentration that protects a dormant pipe from splitting may still leave a pump unable to start. This article sets out what the terms mean, how to read a concentration figure, and which questions decide whether you have a problem or a risk.

Freeze point is not burst point

Published guidance for glycol solutions draws a distinction that the datasheet often collapses into one column.

The freeze point is the temperature at which ice crystals first begin to form in the fluid. At the freeze point the fluid becomes slushy. It does not yet expand with enough force to threaten the pipework, but it is also not pumpable. If the system needs to start and circulate in cold weather, the freeze point is the relevant limit.

The burst point is the temperature at which the cooling fluid expands with enough force to split pipework, crack a heat exchanger or rupture a seal. The burst point is lower — sometimes considerably lower — than the freeze point, because the slush that forms between the two thresholds can accommodate some expansion.

The practical consequence is that the glycol concentration needed for freeze protection is higher than the concentration needed for burst protection. A published comparison for a 10 °F (−12 °C) ambient condition puts the numbers in useful perspective: ethylene glycol requires a concentration of about 26% by volume to provide freeze protection at that temperature, and about 18% to provide burst protection. For propylene glycol, the comparable figures are about 30% for freeze protection and about 21% for burst protection.

Those are illustrative figures from a third-party source. The curve for your specific fluid, at the glycol type and inhibitor package you are actually using, may differ. What does not differ is the principle: the concentration that prevents bursting is lower than the concentration that prevents slush, and a system designed only to the lower number will not circulate in the cold.

What determines whether you need freeze or burst protection

The deciding factor is whether the system ever has to start from cold.

A chilled-water loop that circulates year-round needs freeze protection, because the pumps have to move fluid at the lowest temperature the loop sees, including during a cold start after a power outage. The concentration must hold the freeze point below the lowest ambient temperature the equipment is exposed to, with a margin for the coldest recorded outlier rather than the seasonal average.

A system that sits dormant through the winter and is only drained or re-started in spring may be adequately protected by burst protection. The pipes will not split, even if the fluid turns to slush. But "adequately protected" means protected against splitting — not against being unable to restart.

Systems that alternate between circulation and idle periods over a single cold season are the ones that most often fall between the two. A pipe that spent the week circulating above its freeze point and the weekend sitting still in a cold plant room may have been designed for freeze protection and now, through dilution or top-ups, is only burst-protected. Nobody will know until the pump is asked to start on a Monday morning.

Where the catalogue's figures fit — and where they don't

The Glacier catalogue prints freezing points for several families, and those figures are useful starting points for a system check. For the LM-4B family, for example, the catalogue gives a freezing point of −17.5 °C at 40 wt% concentration and −25 °C at 50 wt%. For the LM-8 series, it lists stock freezing points below −60 °C for the base and L/GL variants, and −50 °C for the LM-850 series.

Read those figures for what they are. A freezing point in a catalogue table describes the stock fluid or one stated dilution, measured under a specific test method. It is not a burst point, and it is not a prediction of what will happen in your loop after three years of make-up water, inhibitor depletion and unspecified top-ups.

The difference between a freeze point and a burst point also explains why the catalogue cannot give you a single concentration that works for every system. Two identical loops in the same city, one circulating year-round and one drained for the winter, need different concentrations, and both need different concentrations from a loop in a colder climate with a different glycol type. The catalogue gives you the freeze point of the fluid; your operating conditions and your start-up requirements give you the target.

A winter-readiness checklist

The questions worth answering before the forecast turns cold:

• What was the design concentration, and what is it today? Measure with a refractometer or hydrometer calibrated for your glycol type. Do not rely on a label written on a drum three years ago.
• What is the lowest temperature the system will actually see? Use the site's coldest recorded ambient, not the seasonal average, and include any unheated plant rooms, rooftop pipe runs or shutdown periods.
• Does the system have to start and circulate at that temperature, or only survive it? The answer decides whether you are specifying to the freeze point or the burst point.
• What were the last pH, inhibitor and conductivity readings? A concentration that is numerically correct will not protect a system whose inhibitor has depleted or whose pH has dropped into the acidic range. A separate check on fluid condition belongs alongside the concentration check.
• What has been used to top up? Plain water dilutes both glycol and inhibitor. If the make-up history is unknown, assume the concentration has drifted downwards and measure it.
• Are you comparing the right glycol type? Ethylene glycol and propylene glycol have different freeze-point and burst-point curves; a concentration figure written for one does not transfer to the other without re-checking the curve.

What this article does not decide

It does not tell you the safe concentration for your system. The figures quoted from the third-party source are illustrative, not a specification, and were measured on specific formulations under laboratory conditions. The catalogue figures are reference values on either the stock fluid or one stated dilution. The concentration your system needs depends on your glycol type, your lowest real-world temperature, your start-up requirement and the condition of your fluid — four things that only a site survey can establish.

It also does not replace a fluid condition review. A correct glycol concentration in degraded, acidic fluid is not protection. If you have not measured pH, inhibitor level or conductivity recently, start there before adjusting the concentration. The system maintenance solution page covers the treatment programmes that apply once you know what is actually in the loop.